A Republican bill with 5 Republican cosponsors · See all 5 cosponsors
Last activity — Read twice and referred to the Committee on Finance.
In committee
Introduced and handed to a committee in the chamber it started in.
The committee holds it, and most bills are never heard from again. A hearing or a committee vote would be news; silence is the usual outcome, and it kills the bill without anyone voting against it.
Its path through Congress
- Introduced
- In Committee
What this bill would do
The STUDENT Act seeks to amend the federal charter of the National Education Association (NEA). It imposes new requirements on the organization regarding political activity, membership, and prohibited beliefs. The bill changes how dues are collected from state or local government employees, requiring affirmative consent and prohibiting payroll deductions. It also prohibits the NEA from participating in political activity or influencing legislation. Additionally, the bill bans certain ideological requirements and strikes or work stoppages. Finally, it repeals a property tax exemption in the District of Columbia.
Yes· 3 of 6
- Scored +5
Does this make what the government does easier for the public to see?
The bill requires the NEA to submit an annual report to Congress and allows members to inspect corporate records.
- Scored +2
Does this protect people from being watched or searched?
The bill grants members the right to inspect the corporation's records for any proper purpose.
- Scored +1
Would middle-income households be better off under this?
The bill mandates affirmative consent for dues, giving employees more direct control over their personal finances.
The opposite· 3 of 8
- Scored -9
Would union members be better off under this?
The bill severely restricts union activities including political contributions, lobbying, and the right to strike.
- Scored -8
Does this strengthen the rights of workers to organise?
The bill significantly curtails union power by prohibiting political activity, legislative influence, and strikes or work stoppages.
- Scored -3
Does this narrow racial gaps in how people are treated?
The bill prohibits the NEA from requiring adherence to beliefs regarding race and critical race theory, which critics argue may reduce racial equity advocacy.
Who it would affect, and how
Potential Positive Impacts for People
-
Increased Financial Transparency and Control for Employees: Under Section 3, the bill requires that employees be notified of their right to refrain from membership and must clearly and affirmatively consent to pay dues. Furthermore, it prohibits the use of payroll deductions for dues, giving employees more direct control over their money.
-
Protection Against Specific Ideologies: Section 4(b)(14) prohibits the NEA from requiring members or staff to affirm or adopt specific beliefs regarding race, sex, or religion, as well as beliefs that promote antisemitism. This may benefit those who wish to avoid those specific ideologies.
-
Ban on Strikes and Work Stoppages: According to Section 4(b)(15), the corporation and its affiliates would be prohibited from calling for or participating in strikes, work stoppages, or slowdowns that affect state or local governments.
-
Enhanced Member Oversight: Section 4(b)(9) provides that any member entitled to vote may inspect the corporation's records for any proper purpose at any time.
-
Prevention of Discrimination and Quotas: Section 4(b)(2) mandates that the corporation and its affiliates shall not discriminate against individuals based on race, color, religion, sex, disability, age, or national origin, nor establish quotas based on those factors.
Potential Negative Impacts for People
-
Restrictions on Political Advocacy: Section 4(b)(1) prevents the corporation and its officers from contributing to, supporting, or participating in any political activity or attempting to influence legislation. This would restrict the organization's ability to advocate for its interests.
-
Burden on Membership Collection: Section 3(b)(3) requires that membership dues cannot be taken via payroll deduction, which would require employees to manage their payments manually rather than through automatic deductions.
-
Potential Legal Action by Attorney General: Under Section 4(b)(11), the Attorney General of the United States is granted the power to bring civil actions against the corporation if it engages in practices inconsistent with its stated purposes or fails to carry out its obligations.
-
Loss of Tax Exemption: Section 5 repeals the property tax exemption for the organization in the District of Columbia.
Groups and Interests Ranking
Every group the model scored this bill for, from -10 to +10. Tap or hover a score for the reason it gave.
- Demographic And Interest Groups
- Would middle-income households be better off under this? — The bill mandates affirmative consent for dues, giving employees more direct control over their personal finances. Would union members be better off under this? — The bill severely restricts union activities including political contributions, lobbying, and the right to strike. Would Black Americans be better off under this? — The bill prohibits the promotion of certain racial justice concepts, which could impact advocacy for racial equity. Would Hispanic Americans be better off under this? — The bill restricts the organization's ability to engage in political advocacy related to immigration. Would households on low incomes be better off under this? — The ban on strikes and work stoppages may reduce the collective bargaining leverage of education employees who are often low-to-middle income. Would women be better off under this? — The bill restricts the organization's ability to advocate for political causes, which may include women's rights issues.
- Economy And Finance
- Does this make the government pay for what it commits to? — The bill increases government revenue by repealing a specific property tax exemption in the District of Columbia. Does this strengthen the rights of workers to organise? — The bill significantly curtails union power by prohibiting political activity, legislative influence, and strikes or work stoppages. Does this cut taxes for small businesses? — The repeal of the District of Columbia property tax exemption specifically targets the NEA's tax-exempt status.
- Governance And Ideology
- Does this make what the government does easier for the public to see? — The bill requires the NEA to submit an annual report to Congress and allows members to inspect corporate records. Does this protect people from being watched or searched? — The bill grants members the right to inspect the corporation's records for any proper purpose.
- Social Issues And Justice
- Does this expand the rights of people with disabilities? — The bill mandates that the NEA shall not discriminate against individuals on the basis of disability. Does this narrow racial gaps in how people are treated? — The bill prohibits the NEA from requiring adherence to beliefs regarding race and critical race theory, which critics argue may reduce racial equity advocacy.
- Education And Technology
- Does this make it easier to use public money at a school other than the local one? — By restricting the political and strike capabilities of the NEA, the bill may indirectly facilitate the movement toward school choice.
- 7/28/2025
- 1 Cosponsor added.
- 7/24/2025
- Read twice and referred to the Committee on Finance.
- 4 Cosponsors added.
- Introduced in Senate
One bill Congress.gov lists as related to this one — companions in the other chamber, earlier versions, and bills this one absorbed or was folded into.
Kevin CramerRepublican · North Dakota
Ted CruzRepublican · Texas
James RischRepublican · Idaho
Pete RickettsRepublican · Nebraska
Tim SheehyRepublican · Montana