A Democratic bill with 2 Democratic cosponsors · See all 2 cosponsors
Last activity — Referred to the Committee on Financial Services, and in addition to the Committee on Energy and Commerce, for a period to be subsequently determined by the Speaker, in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned.
In committee
Introduced and handed to a committee in the chamber it started in.
The committee holds it, and most bills are never heard from again. A hearing or a committee vote would be news; silence is the usual outcome, and it kills the bill without anyone voting against it.
Its path through Congress
- Introduced
- In Committee
What this bill would do
The "Prohibit Auto Insurance Discrimination Act" or "PAID Act" aims to stop private passenger automobile insurers from using specific income-related factors to set insurance rates or determine eligibility. It prohibits using variables like education, occupation, and credit scores to influence premiums. Insurers must submit information to the FTC to ensure their practices do not disproportionately impact certain groups. Additionally, the bill requires all underwriting rules and rate filings to be available for public inspection. This law includes strict enforcement through the FTC and allows for consumer and state legal actions.
Yes· 3 of 21
- Scored +8
Would households on low incomes be better off under this?
The bill specifically targets the removal of proxies that lead to higher insurance rates for lower-income drivers.
- Scored +7
Would Black Americans be better off under this?
The bill helps mitigate potential racial disparities caused by the use of proxy variables like ZIP Code.
- Scored +7
Would Hispanic Americans be better off under this?
The bill helps mitigate potential racial disparities caused by the use of proxy variables like ZIP Code.
The opposite
- Scored -4
Would high-income households be better off under this?
The bill may reduce the benefit of lower rates currently obtained by using affluent proxies.
- Scored -3
Would business owners be better off under this?
The bill increases regulatory compliance burdens and mandates transparency for insurance companies.
- Scored -3
Does this leave more decisions to the states?
The bill limits state-level control over insurance pricing by establishing federal prohibitions and oversight.
Who it would affect, and how
Potential Positive Impacts for People
-
Fairer Pricing for Drivers: By prohibiting the use of income proxies, the bill prevents higher rates from being charged to lower-income drivers and lower rates from being charged to more affluent drivers (Section 2, subsection 5).
-
Increased Transparency: The bill mandates that all underwriting rules and rate filings must be available for public inspection, meaning they can no longer be kept as private trade secrets (Section 3, subsection d).
-
Protection Against Discrimination: Insurers are required to demonstrate through the FTC that their marketing, underwriting, and rating models do not have a disparate impact on groups based on race, religion, sex, disability, or other protected characteristics (Section 3, subsection c).
-
Consumer Accountability: The bill allows individuals to take legal action against insurers for willful or negligent violations, which can include actual damages and attorney's fees (Section 4, subsection b).
-
State Oversight: State attorneys general are empowered to bring civil actions on behalf of their residents to enforce compliance or seek compensation (Section 4, subsection c).
Potential Negative Impacts for People
- Legal Liability for Reasonable Errors: A person or company is not held liable for a violation if they can prove they maintained reasonable procedures to ensure they were following the Act (Section 3, subsection e).
Groups and Interests Ranking
Every group the model scored this bill for, from -10 to +10. Tap or hover a score for the reason it gave.
- Demographic And Interest Groups
- Would households on low incomes be better off under this? — The bill specifically targets the removal of proxies that lead to higher insurance rates for lower-income drivers. Would Black Americans be better off under this? — The bill helps mitigate potential racial disparities caused by the use of proxy variables like ZIP Code. Would Asian Americans be better off under this? — The bill helps mitigate potential racial disparities caused by the use of proxy variables like ZIP Code. Would Hispanic Americans be better off under this? — The bill helps mitigate potential racial disparities caused by the use of proxy variables like ZIP Code. Would Native Americans be better off under this? — The bill helps mitigate potential racial disparities caused by the use of proxy variables like ZIP Code. Would LGBTQ people be better off under this? — The bill provides protections against disparate impact based on sexual orientation and gender identity. Would people with disabilities be better off under this? — The bill mandates that insurance models do not disproportionately impact those with disabilities. Would men be better off under this? — The bill prohibits using gender as a factor in insurance rates. Would people in rural areas be better off under this? — The bill limits the use of ZIP Code and census tract as factors, which often impact rural residents. Would people in cities be better off under this? — The bill limits the use of ZIP Code and census tract as factors, which often impact urban residents. Would women be better off under this? — The bill prohibits using gender as a factor in insurance rates. Would middle-income households be better off under this? — The bill prevents various socio-economic factors from negatively impacting insurance premium rates. Would white Americans be better off under this? — The bill ensures a more standardized approach to insurance pricing based on driving history rather than socio-economic status. Would high-income households be better off under this? — The bill may reduce the benefit of lower rates currently obtained by using affluent proxies. Would business owners be better off under this? — The bill increases regulatory compliance burdens and mandates transparency for insurance companies.
- Social Issues And Justice
- Does this narrow racial gaps in how people are treated? — By banning income proxies like ZIP Code and education, the bill mitigates racial disparities in insurance pricing. Is this likely to lift people out of poverty? — The bill reduces the financial burden on low-income drivers by prohibiting the use of income-related proxies for insurance rates. Does this expand the rights of people with disabilities? — The bill ensures that insurers do not use models that have a disparate impact based on disability. Does this narrow the gap between how men and women are treated? — The bill prohibits using gender as a factor in determining automobile insurance eligibility or rates. Does this expand the rights of LGBTQ people? — The bill protects against disparate impacts based on sexual orientation and gender identity in insurance underwriting.
- Governance And Ideology
- Does this make what the government does easier for the public to see? — The bill increases transparency by requiring underwriting rules and rate filings to be available for public inspection. Does this give the federal government more power? — The bill expands federal authority by empowering the FTC to regulate and enforce auto insurance rating practices. Does this leave more decisions to the states? — The bill limits state-level control over insurance pricing by establishing federal prohibitions and oversight.
- Economy And Finance
- Does this give people more protection from unfair business practices? — The bill enhances consumer protection by prohibiting discriminatory insurance pricing and increasing transparency through public access to underwriting rules.
- 5/29/2025
- Referred to the Committee on Financial Services, and in addition to the Committee on Energy and Commerce, for a period to be subsequently determined by the Speaker, in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned.
- 2 Cosponsors added.
- Introduced in House
Mark TakanoDemocrat · California
Rashida TlaibDemocrat · Michigan