A Democratic bill with 7 Democratic cosponsors · See all 7 cosponsors
Last activity — Read twice and referred to the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs.
In committee
Introduced and handed to a committee in the chamber it started in.
The committee holds it, and most bills are never heard from again. A hearing or a committee vote would be news; silence is the usual outcome, and it kills the bill without anyone voting against it.
Its path through Congress
- Introduced
- In Committee
What this bill would do
The Appraisal Modernization Act seeks to amend the Federal Housing Enterprises Safety and Soundness Act of 1992. It mandates the creation of a public, searchable database containing residential real estate appraisal data. This database aims to track how financial institutions and valuation professionals serve the housing market. Additionally, the bill establishes a consumer right to a reconsideration of value or a subsequent appraisal. Creditors would be required to implement specific review and resolution procedures for these requests.
Yes· 3 of 11
- Scored +7
Does this make what the government does easier for the public to see?
The creation of a public, searchable database significantly increases transparency in the appraisal market.
- Scored +6
Does this narrow racial gaps in how people are treated?
The bill addresses potential racial discrimination in the appraisal process through mandatory reviews and financial redress.
- Scored +5
Would Black Americans be better off under this?
The bill includes mechanisms to identify and address potential discrimination in appraisals.
The opposite
- Scored -4
Does this give people more control over their personal data?
The bill's requirement for a public database containing physical addresses and borrower demographics poses privacy risks.
- Scored -3
Does this protect people from being watched or searched?
The disclosure of itemized appraisal data may conflict with individual privacy interests.
Who it would affect, and how
Potential Positive Impacts for People
-
Increased Transparency through Data Access: The creation of a public, searchable, and downloadable appraisal-level database provides the public, the Federal Government, and State governments with residential real estate appraisal data (Section 2(a) and 2(d)).
-
Empowerment of Borrowers to Challenge Appraisals: Consumers gain the right to request a reconsideration of value or a subsequent appraisal if they believe an appraisal is unsupported, deficient due to unacceptable practices, or reflects discrimination (Section 3(a)(2)(B)).
-
Standardized Dispute Resolution: Creditors must provide written disclosures describing the reconsideration process and use a standardized format for submitting requests, which ensures consumers know how to navigate the process (Section 3(a)(2)(C)).
-
Protection Against Unacceptable Practices: The bill defines "unacceptable appraisal practice"—such as using inaccurate data, crime statistics, or inappropriate comparable properties—giving consumers a basis to challenge poor-quality reports (Section 3(a)(1)(A)).
-
Financial Redress for Discrimination: If a creditor has reason to believe an appraisal reflects discrimination, they must order a subsequent appraisal at their own expense, and the appraiser must reimburse the creditor upon a final determination of discrimination (Section 3(a)(3)(B)).
Potential Negative Impacts for People
-
Privacy Risks: The release of itemized appraisal data, including physical addresses and borrower race/ethnicity, could create risks to a mortgage loan applicant's or borrower's privacy interests (Section 2(e)(1) and 2(e)(2)).
-
Increased Costs for Creditors: Creditors are required to pay for subsequent appraisals at their own expense if material deficiencies or evidence of unacceptable practices are identified (Section 3(a)(3)(A)).
-
Potential Financial Burden on Appraisers: Appraisers may be required to reimburse creditors for the cost of subsequent appraisals if a final determination of discrimination is made (Section 3(a)(3)(B)(ii)).
Groups and Interests Ranking
Every group the model scored this bill for, from -10 to +10. Tap or hover a score for the reason it gave.
- Demographic And Interest Groups
- Would Black Americans be better off under this? — The bill includes mechanisms to identify and address potential discrimination in appraisals. Would Asian Americans be better off under this? — The bill includes mechanisms to identify and address potential discrimination in appraisals. Would Hispanic Americans be better off under this? — The bill includes mechanisms to identify and address potential discrimination in appraisals. Would Native Americans be better off under this? — The bill includes mechanisms to identify and address potential discrimination in appraisals. Would households on low incomes be better off under this? — Increased protections against discriminatory or inaccurate appraisals can benefit lower-income borrowers.
- Governance And Ideology
- Does this make what the government does easier for the public to see? — The creation of a public, searchable database significantly increases transparency in the appraisal market. Does this protect the right to fair treatment by the courts? — The bill provides consumers with structured procedures to challenge and correct appraisal errors. Does this give the federal government more power? — The bill expands federal oversight and data collection responsibilities regarding the housing market. Does this protect people from being watched or searched? — The disclosure of itemized appraisal data may conflict with individual privacy interests.
- Social Issues And Justice
- Does this narrow racial gaps in how people are treated? — The bill addresses potential racial discrimination in the appraisal process through mandatory reviews and financial redress. Does this make housing cost less? — Increased transparency and recourse in appraisals can support more equitable and efficient housing markets.
- Economy And Finance
- Does this give people more protection from unfair business practices? — The bill enhances consumer protections by providing a right to challenge appraisals and access a public database.
- Education And Technology
- Does this give people more control over their personal data? — The bill's requirement for a public database containing physical addresses and borrower demographics poses privacy risks.
- 12/16/2025
- 1 Cosponsor added.
- 7/28/2025
- 1 Cosponsor added.
- 7/17/2025
- Read twice and referred to the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs.
- 5 Cosponsors added.
- Introduced in Senate
Angela AlsobrooksDemocrat · Maryland
Richard BlumenthalDemocrat · Connecticut
Cory BookerDemocrat · New Jersey
Lisa Blunt RochesterDemocrat · Delaware
Andy KimDemocrat · New Jersey
Mark WarnerDemocrat · Virginia
Elizabeth WarrenDemocrat · Massachusetts