Victoria Spartz (R-IN)
Addressing Anti-Competitive Health Care Contract Clauses Act
A Republican bill with no cosponsors
Last activity — Referred to the Committee on Energy and Commerce, and in addition to the Committee on the Judiciary, for a period to be subsequently determined by the Speaker, in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned.
In committee
Introduced and handed to a committee in the chamber it started in.
The committee holds it, and most bills are never heard from again. A hearing or a committee vote would be news; silence is the usual outcome, and it kills the bill without anyone voting against it.
Its path through Congress
- Introduced
- In Committee
What this bill would do
H.R. 3020, the "Addressing Anti-Competitive Health Care Contract Clauses Act," directs the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to study the effects of anticompetitive clauses in contracts between health insurers and healthcare providers. The study will evaluate the impact of these clauses on healthcare consolidation, consumer prices, and access to care. The bill also requires the GAO to assess the enforcement capabilities of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) regarding antitrust laws related to these clauses.
Potential Positive Impacts for People:
-
Reduced Healthcare Costs: Section 2(a)(1) tasks the GAO with evaluating the effects of anticompetitive contract clauses on prices paid by consumers for medical services. If the study identifies that these clauses contribute to higher prices, it could lead to legislative or administrative actions that lower healthcare costs for individuals.
-
Improved Access to Healthcare: Section 2(a)(1) also directs the GAO to evaluate the effects of these clauses on consumer access to healthcare. If the study finds that these clauses limit access, addressing this issue could improve healthcare access for individuals.
-
Increased Transparency: Section 2(a)(2) requires a list of actions taken by the FTC and DOJ related to these clauses, potentially increasing transparency in the healthcare market. Section 3 defines "gag clauses" which restrict the disclosure of price and quality information to consumers, implying that addressing these clauses could increase consumer access to such information.
Potential Negative Impacts for People:
This bill does not appear to contain any explicit potential negative impacts for people based on the provided text.
Yes· 3 of 30
- Scored +4
Would households on low incomes be better off under this?
Lower healthcare costs and improved access are most impactful for low-income households.
- Scored +3
Would people over 65 be better off under this?
Seniors typically utilize healthcare more frequently and benefit more from reduced costs and improved access.
- Scored +3
Would middle-income households be better off under this?
Middle-class households benefit from reduced healthcare spending and better price transparency.
The opposite
No question was scored the opposite.
Groups and Interests Ranking
Every group the model scored this bill for, from -10 to +10. Tap or hover a score for the reason it gave.
- Demographic And Interest Groups
- Would households on low incomes be better off under this? — Lower healthcare costs and improved access are most impactful for low-income households. Would middle-income households be better off under this? — Middle-class households benefit from reduced healthcare spending and better price transparency. Would people with disabilities be better off under this? — People with disabilities often have higher healthcare needs and benefit significantly from improved access and lower costs. Would retired people be better off under this? — Retirees are heavy users of healthcare and benefit from lower costs and better access. Would people in rural areas be better off under this? — Rural residents often face greater access challenges and consolidation issues addressed by the study. Would people over 65 be better off under this? — Seniors typically utilize healthcare more frequently and benefit more from reduced costs and improved access. Would Black Americans be better off under this? — Improvements in healthcare access and cost can help reduce systemic disparities. Would Asian Americans be better off under this? — Improvements in healthcare access and cost can help reduce systemic disparities. Would children be better off under this? — Potential for lower healthcare costs affects all ages, including children. Would Hispanic Americans be better off under this? — Improvements in healthcare access and cost can help reduce systemic disparities. Would immigrants be better off under this? — Improved healthcare access and lower costs benefit immigrant populations. Would LGBTQ people be better off under this? — General improvement in healthcare access and affordability. Would men be better off under this? — General improvement in healthcare access and affordability. Would people in middle age be better off under this? — Potential for lower healthcare costs affects all ages, including middle aged. Would Native Americans be better off under this? — Improvements in healthcare access and cost can help reduce systemic disparities. Would students be better off under this? — General improvement in healthcare affordability. Would union members be better off under this? — Union members often rely on negotiated health plans that would benefit from a more competitive market. Would people in cities be better off under this? — General improvement in healthcare affordability and access. Would veterans be better off under this, taking everything together? — General improvement in healthcare access and affordability. Would white Americans be better off under this? — General improvements in healthcare cost and access benefit all racial groups. Would women be better off under this? — General improvement in healthcare access and affordability. Would people in their twenties and thirties be better off under this? — Potential for lower healthcare costs affects all ages, including young adults. Would high-income households be better off under this? — Higher income households benefit less from small price reductions in healthcare.
- Healthcare
- Does this make health care easier to get in general? — The GAO will evaluate how anticompetitive clauses limit consumer access to healthcare providers. Does this lower what a hospital stay costs? — The study focuses on clauses that contribute to higher medical service prices paid by consumers. Does this lower what people pay for private health insurance? — Identifying anticompetitive practices may lead to market reforms that reduce premium costs over time.
- Governance And Ideology
- Does this make what the government does easier for the public to see? — The bill requires a GAO report and a list of agency actions, increasing transparency regarding antitrust enforcement. Does this protect the individual right to speak freely? — The focus on 'gag clauses' aims to allow the disclosure of price and quality information to consumers. Does this give the federal government more power? — The bill empowers federal agencies (GAO, FTC, DOJ) to investigate and potentially regulate private healthcare contracts.
- Economy And Finance
- Does this give people more protection from unfair business practices? — The bill seeks to identify and potentially eliminate anticompetitive clauses that raise prices for consumers.
- 4/24/2025
- Referred to the Committee on Energy and Commerce, and in addition to the Committee on the Judiciary, for a period to be subsequently determined by the Speaker, in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned.
- Introduced in House