Diana Harshbarger (R-TN)
To ensure national uniformity with respect to certain requirements relating to preterm infant formula, and for other purposes.
A Republican bill with 1 Democratic cosponsor · See all 2 cosponsors
Last activity — Referred to the House Committee on Energy and Commerce.
In committee
Introduced and handed to a committee in the chamber it started in.
The committee holds it, and most bills are never heard from again. A hearing or a committee vote would be news; silence is the usual outcome, and it kills the bill without anyone voting against it.
Its path through Congress
- Introduced
- In Committee
What this bill would do
This bill aims to create national uniformity regarding requirements for preterm infant formula. It directs the Secretary of Health and Human Services to conduct a study on the availability of this formula and the various laws and regulations surrounding its production and safety. The study includes looking into whether the Food and Drug Administration should require premarket approval for these products. For a two-year period, the bill establishes a temporary preemption of State laws and regulations that differ from specific Federal acts regarding preterm infant formula. This includes a specific exception for civil or criminal actions involving willful misconduct that causes death or serious physical injury.
Yes· 3 of 7
- Scored +5
Would children be better off under this?
The bill addresses safety and availability of essential nutrition for infants.
- Scored +5
Does this give the federal government more power?
The bill increases federal power by preempting State laws regarding preterm infant formula.
- Scored +4
Would business owners be better off under this?
Manufacturers benefit from national uniformity and preemption of varied state laws.
The opposite
- Scored -5
Does this leave more decisions to the states?
The bill reduces states' rights by preempting their ability to regulate preterm infant formula for two years.
- Scored -2
Does this protect the right to fair treatment by the courts?
The bill places a higher burden of proof on plaintiffs in certain civil actions.
Who it would affect, and how
Potential Positive Impacts for People
-
Increased Information on Formula Availability: The Secretary of Health and Human Services will study the availability of preterm infant formula in the United States (Section 1(a)(1)(A)).
-
Investigation of Safety and Regulatory Standards: The study will examine Federal and State laws and regulations relating to the design, development, manufacture, and safety of preterm infant formula (Section 1(a)(1)(B)).
-
Potential for Stricter Federal Oversight: The bill directs a study on whether requiring manufacturers to obtain premarket approval from the Food and Drug Administration would be appropriate (Section 1(a)(1)(C)).
-
Protection Against Willful Misconduct: There is an exception that allows for civil or criminal actions if a manufacturer engages in willful misconduct that causes death or serious physical injury (Section 1(b)(3)(A)).
Potential Negative Impacts for People
-
Limitation of State Regulatory Authority: For a period of two years, States and their political subdivisions are prohibited from establishing or enforcing requirements for preterm infant formula that are different from or in addition to certain Federal requirements (Section 1(b)(2)).
-
Dismissal of Legal Actions: Any pending civil or criminal action that seeks to implement or enforce a requirement preempted by this bill must be dismissed (Section 1(b)(4)).
-
Burden of Proof on Plaintiffs: In cases involving willful misconduct, the plaintiff carries the burden of proving their claim by clear and convincing evidence (Section 1(b)(3)(C)).
Groups and Interests Ranking
Every group the model scored this bill for, from -10 to +10. Tap or hover a score for the reason it gave.
- Demographic And Interest Groups
- Would children be better off under this? — The bill addresses safety and availability of essential nutrition for infants. Would business owners be better off under this? — Manufacturers benefit from national uniformity and preemption of varied state laws. Would women be better off under this? — The bill relates to infant nutrition, which often impacts maternal and family health. Would households on low incomes be better off under this? — Improved availability of preterm formula can benefit low-income families.
- Healthcare
- Does this make health care easier to get in general? — The bill aims to increase availability and safety oversight of essential preterm infant formula.
- Economy And Finance
- Does this give people more protection from unfair business practices? — The bill may improve consumer protection by studying the need for stricter FDA premarket approval for preterm formula.
- Governance And Ideology
- Does this give the federal government more power? — The bill increases federal power by preempting State laws regarding preterm infant formula. Does this leave more decisions to the states? — The bill reduces states' rights by preempting their ability to regulate preterm infant formula for two years. Does this protect the right to fair treatment by the courts? — The bill places a higher burden of proof on plaintiffs in certain civil actions.
- 4/24/2025
- 1 Cosponsor added.
- 3/24/2025
- Referred to the House Committee on Energy and Commerce.
- 1 Cosponsor added.
- Introduced in House
Mike CareyRepublican · Ohio
Bradley SchneiderDemocrat · Illinois