A Democratic bill with no cosponsors
Last activity — Referred to the Subcommittee on Border Security and Enforcement.
In committee
Introduced and handed to a committee in the chamber it started in.
The committee holds it, and most bills are never heard from again. A hearing or a committee vote would be news; silence is the usual outcome, and it kills the bill without anyone voting against it.
Its path through Congress
- Introduced
- In Committee
What this bill would do
The Homeland Security Improvement Act aims to increase transparency, accountability, and community engagement within the Department of Homeland Security. It establishes an independent Border Oversight Commission to provide independent oversight of border security activities and develop policy recommendations. The bill also creates an Office of the Ombudsman for Border and Immigration-Related Concerns to investigate complaints and provide redress. Additionally, it mandates enhanced training for U.S. Customs and Border Protection agents and officers. The legislation includes provisions for better management of ports of entry and stricter requirements for data collection regarding border stops. Finally, it imposes limitations on the separation of families during immigration enforcement.
Yes· 3 of 17
- Scored +6
Does this make what the government does easier for the public to see?
The bill establishes an independent oversight commission and an Ombudsman with mandatory public reporting requirements.
- Scored +5
Would children be better off under this?
The bill prohibits family separation for deterrence and mandates specialized training for handling vulnerable children.
- Scored +5
Would immigrants be better off under this?
The bill protects against family separation, provides an Ombudsman for redress, and mandates better treatment of vulnerable populations.
The opposite
No question was scored the opposite.
Who it would affect, and how
Potential Positive Impacts for People
-
Independent Oversight: The establishment of the Department of Homeland Security Border Oversight Commission provides independent review of border enforcement policies, strategies, and programs (Section 2(a)(4)).
-
Protection of Rights: The Commission is tasked with evaluating policies to protect due process, civil and human rights of border residents and visitors, and private property rights of land owners (Section 2(a)(4)(B)).
-
Redress for Complaints: The Office of the Ombudsman is authorized to establish a process to receive, investigate, and resolve complaints, providing potential redress such as immigration relief or monetary damages (Section 3(a)(4)(1)).
-
Support for Victims: The Ombudsman is designated to assist individuals and families who have been victims of crimes near the border or impacted by the use of force by the Department (Section s 3(a)(4)(3)).
-
Improved Training: The bill mandates specific training for agents and officers regarding community relations, de-escalation tactics, and the protection of civil and human rights (Section 4(b)).
-
Protection Against Retaliation: Complainants who file grievances with the Ombudsman are protected from retaliatory action by law enforcement (Section 3(a)(6)(2)).
-
Family Unity: The Act prohibits the removal of children from parents or legal guardians solely for the purpose of deterring migration or promoting compliance with immigration laws (Section 8(a)).
Potential Negative Impacts for People
-
Potential for Unintended Separation: While there are restrictions, the bill allows for the removal of children if a state court or child welfare agency determines it is in the child's best interest due to danger of abuse or neglect (Section 8(b)(1)).
-
No Immunity for Legal Proceedings: The filing of a complaint with the Ombudsman does not confer immunity or impact any existing removal or criminal proceedings against a complainant (Section s 3(a)(6)(3)).
Groups and Interests Ranking
Every group the model scored this bill for, from -10 to +10. Tap or hover a score for the reason it gave.
- Demographic And Interest Groups
- Would children be better off under this? — The bill prohibits family separation for deterrence and mandates specialized training for handling vulnerable children. Would immigrants be better off under this? — The bill protects against family separation, provides an Ombudsman for redress, and mandates better treatment of vulnerable populations. Would Hispanic Americans be better off under this? — The bill provides enhanced oversight and a redress process for those impacted by immigration enforcement. Would households on low incomes be better off under this? — The bill creates a process for individuals to receive redress, including potential monetary damages. Would people with disabilities be better off under this? — The bill requires the Ombudsman to provide accommodations for disabilities during the complaint process. Would people in cities be better off under this? — The bill includes training for officers specifically addressing safety during interventions in urban areas.
- Social Issues And Justice
- Does this change how police departments operate? — The bill implements new training, oversight via a Commission, and an Ombudsman to improve law enforcement conduct. Does this tighten control of the border? — The bill enhances security through improved agent training, better port of entry management, and oversight of enforcement activities. Does this narrow racial gaps in how people are treated? — The bill mandates data collection on the perceived race of individuals during patrol stops to monitor for disparities. Does this make child care cost less? — The bill provides protections against the separation of children from their parents. Does this expand the rights of people with disabilities? — The Ombudsman is required to provide accommodations for disabilities when processing complaints.
- Governance And Ideology
- Does this make what the government does easier for the public to see? — The bill establishes an independent oversight commission and an Ombudsman with mandatory public reporting requirements. Does this protect people from being watched or searched? — The bill mandates privacy considerations regarding border-related technologies and protecting personally identifiable information.
- Economy And Finance
- Does this make it easier to run a small business? — The bill mandates the Commission to consider the impact of border policies on cross-border trade and commerce.
- Education And Technology
- Does this get reliable internet to more people? — The bill establishes an online detainee locator system and a centralized online complaint portal.
- Environment Energy And Infrastructure
- Does this invest in rural communities? — The bill includes training and policies specifically addressing safety and operations in rural and remote locations.
- National Security And Foreign Policy
- Does this increase the pay, pensions or support veterans receive? — The bill includes provisions for tribal officials in the oversight of border subcommittees.
- 2/27/2025
- Referred to the Committee on Homeland Security, and in addition to the Committees on Ways and Means, and the Judiciary, for a period to be subsequently determined by the Speaker, in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned.
- Referred to the Subcommittee on Border Security and Enforcement.
- Introduced in House
One bill Congress.gov lists as related to this one — companions in the other chamber, earlier versions, and bills this one absorbed or was folded into.